Friday, 17 August 2007

Blog 3- Dutch Pavilion- Citizens and Subjects by Aernout Mik


This was a very interesting peice, and possibly one of my favorite at the Biennale. It focuses on the "notion of the nation state in the present dat sircumstances pf the so-called West and ask how we can negotiate its prospects vis-a-vis the challenges posed by the enduring state of anxiety stemming from various threats, real or imagined." This exhibit somehwat reminded me of 1984 by George Orwell, or the 2006 film Children of Men. The exhibit had many television screens all over the pavilion showing, "training exercises in whichi police learn and practive methods of enforcing the law against refugees, as well as real circumstances in which these acquired techniques are applied." Most all of the techniques used in the training video were violent and threatening. Images from Children of Men instantly popped into my head of the antagonist traveling through refugee camps in an apocolyptic England, giving seens of intense inhumanity towards humanity, a cruel dictatorship.

Throughout the exhibition the differences between "citizens" and "subjects" is stressed. A subject is a person who is under the rule or authority of a sovereign, stae or a governing power and who owes allegiance and obedience. A citizen, on the other hand, are those with rights, entitiled to the full privileges of belonging to a state or nation. As I sat there watching the training videos it was obvious that the men and organizations conducting them were preparing for possible emergencies where such force would be needed. This brings about an important question. How do you prepare for situations in a new world were so many different real, or imagined, threats exsists, in a post 9/11 world. How should governments prepare for situations where national security is at jeapordy? Is it possible to use nonviolence to combat and increasing violent world? Can you fight bombs with words?

This is a nice thought, that peace can prevail, but it's unrealistic. There are so many different peoples, races, beliefs, groups, religions, etc. that no matter what we do, no matter how many treaties are signed, no matter how many meetings politicians conduct, how many hands are shaken, there will always be some kind of threat. So can you find violence with non violence? Perhaps, I hope so. Ghandhi did it, but that was in an age when there weren't suicide bombers itching to get close to an enemy. I think it is reasonable to prepare for such situations where extreme force is needed, but it still scares the shit out of me.

No comments: