Tuesday, 28 August 2007
Franco la Cecla's, Getting lost and the localized mind, presents the ways that people attempt to orient themselves while lost. The feeling of being lost and the anxiety that is a result of being lost are very overwhelming, causing one to feel almost sick and disoriented. In my own experiences of feeling lost in unfamiliar places, I find that I often over-react. The fear that is felt while lost is sometimes stronger than the act of actually being lost. The author questions whether it is possibly to be truly lost in today's world. With technology the way it is, with maps, GPS, internet, etc. can one become truly lost? Obviously in terrains such as the Amazon forest, or a desert, or any other place where orientation can be impaired one can become entirely lost. It is often overwhelming to be in an unfamiliar city as well. In a city, however, one can easily use a map to help navigate, while in a forest or a desert it would be much more difficult to navigate without prior knowledge of the area.
La Cecla also question's whether it is possible to fully immerse one's self into a foreign culture. No matter, how long you are a part of a foreign culture will you ever be able to blend in seemlessly? This is difficult. Obviously things such as appearance may greatly hinder the complete immersion into a culture. In my time in Italy I have tried to immerse myself as much as possible. Although it's difficult to do such a thing in only a month's time I feel like I have done rather well. I speak Italian as much as possible, ordering food at restaruants, paying for groceries, and even having small conversations with Italians using Italian rather than English. It's a small step, but I feel that it has helped alot, just speaking the language, eating the food, using public transportation, studying, all of this has helped me feel more a part of the Italian culture. I'm far far far away from being completely immersed in Italian culture, but at least I've tried. I found that if I welcome the uncomfortable situations, the woes of travel, making mistake after mistake after mistake, if I welcome all of this with open arms, and accept the akward uncomfortable feeling it helps. I look forward to getting lost, to trying to speak with Italians in Italian, all of it because of the growth it provides me.
After studying the frescoes in the Sistine chapel last year, I was very excited to view one of Michelangelo's most famous works. Unfortunately, due to the overcrowding of the chapel by other tourists, I wasn't able to fully appreciate the work. Regardless of how many people were crammed into the chapel, it was still amazing to see the frescos. While studying the Sistine chapel back home I had actually imagined the work being far larger than it really is. I wasn't dissapointed though. The Last Judgement fresco on the main wall is incredible. It's strange to think that Michelangelo actually preferred sculpture to painting because he spent so much time on the frescos in the Sistine Chapel. As I walked down the chapel, following the central fresco on the ceiling with such images as God creating night and day, separating land and sea, and the creation of Adam, I was taken aback by how impressive the frescos truly are. Looking at the images in an art history book in the U.S. just isn't the same as viewing these works in person.
The part of the chapel which I found most impressive was the Last Judgement fresco. The detail with which Michelangelo painted is astounding. I have seen many students studying painting and it doesn't come close to comparing with what Michelangelo did. The modeling of the bodies in the paintings followed the too familiar characteristic of muscle bound forms that is so prominent in painting and sculpture. Michelangelo included a self-portrait hidden in the Last Judgement fresco. He painted himself as the body of skin that is being held near the top center of the frescos. It's strange that he just painted skin, there is no body to the form, just his skin as if it were a costume.
It's not difficult to imagine what it must have been like fore those who once attended mass in the chapel. The sheer size and detail of the fresco is absolutely breath-taking was surely inspired much reverence in all that were lucky enough to have attended any event within the chapel.
I enjoyed Bernini's depiction of David very much. What pleased me most about the sculpture is Bernini's representation of David's body in motion. The statue is in the motion of drawing back his sling with the stone that will smite Goliath. The young boy is drawn to nearly full extent, just before his body explodes in to that fast motion to rocket the stone towards the giant. Bernini accurately represents David's anatomy here. The youth's body is relaxed as he finishes drawing the sling back, the muscles have not yet begun to flex in the forward throwing motion. The viewers gets a sense of the fluidity of David's movement through the curve of David's torso.
Bernini's representation of David's musculator is very well done, however, the musculator is that of a grown man. David was a young teenager when he defeated Goliath in battle. This seems to be a common representation of the young hero. Michelangelo's, David, in L'Accadamia also represented David with a very young face, but an incredibly mature, muscular body. Donatello's representation of David, is one that I find much more convincing. The bronze cast is only a few feet high but the body and the facial features of David are convincingly that of a boy of about 13-15 years old. This representation by Donatello is accurate, but something is lost to many viewers. Most people want the hero to be a strong, masculine representation, which is likely what Michelangelo and Bernini represented David in such a manner. Personally, I prefer Donatello's youthful David, over Bernini's and Michelangelo's, just because it is more accurate to the story it represents. This isn't to say that Bernini's representation of David is poorly done, it is one of the more skillyfully sculpted statues I have seen.
Bernini's ability to represent motion and musculature with stone is astounding. When viewing the David in the middle of the gallery one can sense an excitement. The view of the youth drawing back his sling n the moment just before he launches the stone at the giants head is thrilling. Both Donatello and Michelangelo chose to represent David in the moments after the battle, the climax has already past. In Bernini's representation of David the youth hasn't yet slayed the giant. As one views the statue one is allowed to immagine the giant Goliath in the distance, advancing on David. The viewers is pulled into the Bernini's, David, more than they are when they view the sculptures.
The Duomo, desgined by Brunelleschi and completed in 1434 is the fourth largest cathedral in the world. As I entered the cathedral I was taken aback by how large it is. It was obvious how large the cathedral is after viewing it from the outside, but I didn't really appreciate how large it truly was until I entered. The ceiling is so far above those on the floor. There are frescos painted by Paolo Uccello in the cathedral, but the interior of the cathedral was not as lavishly decorated as some of the other sites we have visited.This was actually rather pleasant. It was much easier on the eyes, and it allowed those inside the church to focus on the few frescos that were there rather than trying to look at an entire cathedral of frescos.
Giotto designed the bell tower which stands 20 feet lower than the dome designed by Brunelleshi. The tower was constructed more for the asthetics of the square in which the cathedral resides rather than for practical use. The Baptistery near that cathedral is famous for its massive east doors desgined by Ghiberti. The south doors of the Baptistery were desgined by Andrea Pisano. These doors were entered in a competiton set by the church and Ghiberti's design won the commision. Ghiberti's design of these doors, which were bronze cast, marks the beginning of the Renaissance.
I remember seeing the mosaic tiles of the Baptistery while studying art history. The old testament representation of God stares down upon veiwers with that hard, forceful look that is so often given to old testament representations of God. I remember my professor saying that the old testament God, the representation with the beard, was meant to evoke an almost fearful response in the viewers of the mosaics. Causing faith through fear. The new testament God, as I was told by my professor, is meant to be a kinder, more friendly representation. As I looked up at the mosaic tiles, I could understand what my professor was saying. His fade had a clear disapproval. I can imagine it inspired, or scared, many followers over the last couple centuries to attend church.
Friday, 17 August 2007
Blog 5- Florence, The Uffizi Gallery and L'Accadamia
Uffizi
Paolo Uccello, The Battle of San Romano, 1436
This painting by Paolo Uccello depicts the victorious of Florence of Siena at San Romano in June of 1432. My immediate receation to this painting was a little confusion. The artist was obviously attempting to give a sense of deep space in the painting. The hills in the background give a slight sense of space, but overall the effect is lost to the viewer. This painting had one of the first attempts by an artist to depict space using a perspective which recides from foreground to background. Uccello was doing something that other artists weren't doing, he was setting the stepping stones for later artists to create mathematical perspective. In the foreground the lances of many of the soldiers fall into perspective lines, all set at angles pointing to a percieved vanishing point near the center of the painting. These first attempts, although somewhat correct in theory, fail to present a convincing sense of depth in the painting. Realistically, it would not be the lances which need to be set to perspective lines because they are controlled by the soldiers depicted in the paintings. It is the setting of the hills and the actual ground on which the soldiers walk that must contain the characteristics of perspective for the sense of depth to be convincing. Uccello, even made wounded soldiers fallen in battle lie on the ground in a gridded fashion, either lying perfectly horizontally from left to right or along the perspective lines which recede into the distant vanishing point. Although, he failed to depict convincing depth in the painting, this was an essential painting in the development of convincing perspective in art.
Artemisia Gentileschi, Judith Slaying Holofernes, 1652
This painting of Judith cutting Holofernes is incredibly violent. The sword weilded by the woman cuts through the neck of the dieing Holofernes, blood gushing from the large wound. When I first viewed this painting it seemed incredibly out of place in the gallery. The painting was surrounding by gentle iconic religious art, and here in the midst of these is the absolutely brutal, convincing painting of a man being savagely murder by one woman as another woman holds him down. The painting is very effective in capturing the eye of viewers through its sheer shock value. Not many painting created during this time period were blantantly shocking the way this one is. This shock value, reminds me of the frescos and mosiacs often found in churches, or on the facades of churches where demons sworm past souls dragging them in down into the bowels of hell. These paintings were meant to shoch and terrify the viewers to be good so they wouldn't end up with the same fate of the souls being dragged to hell by demonic figures. I'm not sure of the significance the story behind the painting, Judith Slaying Holofernes, but the brutallity was obviously effective in evoking emotion amoung viewers both today and in the past. The dutchess whom originally owned the painting had it removed from her palace because it was too powerful an image, causing great discomfort in the dutchess.
L'Accadamia
This has possibly been the highlight of my art viewing thus far during the trip, apart from the Biennale exhibits from Venice. Michelangelo's, David, is absolutely breath-taking. When I studied it in art history at UO I never realized how large the actual sculpture was. The massage marble form towered 24 feet above the ground floor in the large central gallery of L'Accadamia. The anatomy of the statue was suprisingly accurate. The veins in the youth's arm swelled with blood, just as they would have in real life. The youth's enormous hands draw the viewer's eye to the sling and rock which the young boy carries. Michelangelo, acquired the large marble slab from another artist who had begun another sculpture, but found a crack in the slab and deemed it unusable. Fortunately, Michelangelo was able to create one of the most prolific sculptures in history with the discarded marble.
Blog 4- Arsenale- Yto Barrada
This piece reminds me of the environmental movement that has been going on over the recent decades. There is a need to protect public spaces within urban areas from because big businesses are trying to buy out these spaces to put in a Super Walmart or a starbucks.In Moroco public spaces are being destroyed to create hotels and tourists locations so they can boost their economy. I haven't got anything against morroco trying to boost their eceonomy, I do think it is sad and wrong that these protected forested areas that were once protected by the Morocon Government through protective laws are being used to try and bring tourism into a region. I also wouldnt be at all surpised if many Morocon residents an citizens completely disagreed with what I am saying, I don't know what it is like living their so for all I know these new hotels and resorts will help hundreds, maybe even thousands but food on their tables to help feed their families.
However, this situation reminds me of when the US Government was trying to open 600,000 sq miles of Alaskan National resrve to drill for oil. This was protected land which was the habitat for Karaboo and other native animal. Fortunately, the bill didnt pass and the land remainded, "protected"... for now anyway. What is the point of calling it a protected nature reserve if the government has the ability to lift the laws and bulldoze it all away so they can put in some new store or super shopping center? If the government can just do this than the park was never really "protected" in the first place was it? I think it is sad that people are so willing to destroy for money, the cancerous capitalism. The land that was going to be drilled in Alaska was land where Karaboo lived and had the bill been passed their habitat would have been destroyed. People were willing to completely destroy an endangered species only habitat and possibly wipe the karaboo completely off the face of the earth, never to return, just so we could save a buck or two on a tank of gas to power our SUV's
This makes me sick, I kind of think that humans beings are a virus to planet earth. We have done so much damage to the environment, we have completely annihalated species, thousands of species, dumped deadly toxic chemicals into rivers, lakes, and oceans, done nuclear testing and made regions completely unfit for any animals to live in, and not to mention global warming. We are literally killing the earth. It is kinda of nice to see that people are starting to open thier eyes a bit with documentaries such as, an inconvenient truth, coming out. People are starting to try and slow the negative effects we are having on the earth, but if you ask me, its far too little, far too late. We need to protect the environment from pollution and commercialization now rather than handing the results of our mistakes down to our children's generations.
Sorry about that little rant. The exhibit by Yto Barrada is a small comment on a far larger global issue. It's sad and pathetic to think that we are so willing to destroy "protected" spaces for commericialization.
Blog 3- Dutch Pavilion- Citizens and Subjects by Aernout Mik
This was a very interesting peice, and possibly one of my favorite at the Biennale. It focuses on the "notion of the nation state in the present dat sircumstances pf the so-called West and ask how we can negotiate its prospects vis-a-vis the challenges posed by the enduring state of anxiety stemming from various threats, real or imagined." This exhibit somehwat reminded me of 1984 by George Orwell, or the 2006 film Children of Men. The exhibit had many television screens all over the pavilion showing, "training exercises in whichi police learn and practive methods of enforcing the law against refugees, as well as real circumstances in which these acquired techniques are applied." Most all of the techniques used in the training video were violent and threatening. Images from Children of Men instantly popped into my head of the antagonist traveling through refugee camps in an apocolyptic England, giving seens of intense inhumanity towards humanity, a cruel dictatorship.
Throughout the exhibition the differences between "citizens" and "subjects" is stressed. A subject is a person who is under the rule or authority of a sovereign, stae or a governing power and who owes allegiance and obedience. A citizen, on the other hand, are those with rights, entitiled to the full privileges of belonging to a state or nation. As I sat there watching the training videos it was obvious that the men and organizations conducting them were preparing for possible emergencies where such force would be needed. This brings about an important question. How do you prepare for situations in a new world were so many different real, or imagined, threats exsists, in a post 9/11 world. How should governments prepare for situations where national security is at jeapordy? Is it possible to use nonviolence to combat and increasing violent world? Can you fight bombs with words?
This is a nice thought, that peace can prevail, but it's unrealistic. There are so many different peoples, races, beliefs, groups, religions, etc. that no matter what we do, no matter how many treaties are signed, no matter how many meetings politicians conduct, how many hands are shaken, there will always be some kind of threat. So can you find violence with non violence? Perhaps, I hope so. Ghandhi did it, but that was in an age when there weren't suicide bombers itching to get close to an enemy. I think it is reasonable to prepare for such situations where extreme force is needed, but it still scares the shit out of me.